Tuesday, February 26, 2008

Annals of American History: The century old torture debate

It's like Déjà vu — all over again! Only last time it was the the "water cure" and the counterinsurgency in the Philippines.

read more | digg story

From the end of the New Yorker article:
"But where is that vast national outburst of astounded horror which an old-fashioned America would have predicted at the reading of such news?" the World asked. "Is it lost somewhere in the 8,000 miles that divide us from the scenes of these abominations? Is it led astray by the darker skins of the alien race among which these abominations are perpetrated? Or is it rotted away by that inevitable demoralization which the wrong-doing of a great nation must inflict on the consciences of the least of its citizens?"

Responding to the verdict in the Glenn court-martial, Judge Advocate General Davis had suggested that the question it implicitly posed—how much was global power worth in other people’s pain?—was one no moral nation could legitimately ask. As the investigation of the water cure ended and the memory of faraway torture faded, Americans answered it with their silence.

No comments: